Warning:
JavaScript is turned OFF. None of the links on this page will work until it is reactivated.
If you need help turning JavaScript On, click here.
This Concept Map, created with IHMC CmapTools, has information related to: Group 2, Miller believes that social democracy may not be the ideal to strive for in every situation therefore (ArgScheme: modus ponens) Miller is suspicious of the claim that human flourishing is always best served by democracy and the conception of universal rights, it is not clear to Miller that some willingness to surrender autonomy and authority is always an illegitimate or immoral choice therefore (ArgScheme: modus ponens) if, it is not clear to Miller that some willingness to surrender autonomy and authority is always an illegitimate or immoral choice, then Miller believes that social democracy may not be the ideal to strive for in every situation, many Chinese people are considerably more afraid of disorder, of the failure of authority, of the possibility of an unsettling a system which is navigable for the ordinary Chinese system, than they are of lacking rights SUPPORTS Universal rights, when they seem to entail the sorts of institutions we count as necessary for their fulfillment: freedoms of speech, movement assembly, and a gov't elected by the people, are not worthy of the sort of respect we assume they should command, Without this discussion the recommendations for openness that "universal rights" entails invites situations of conflict without habits of arbitrating and engaging in such conflict productively therefore (ArgScheme: modus ponens) if Without this discussion the recommendations for openness that "universal rights" entails invites situations of conflict without habits of arbitrating and engaging in such conflict productively, then Miller is not aruging that universal rights should be denied based on that grounds that democratic social life may not promote their flouishing, but that it should not be encouraged in a setting where that may be the case, universal human rights entails democracy therefore (ArgScheme: modus ponens) If universal human rights entails democracy, then universal rights should not be denied on the grounds that democratic social life may not promote flourishing, Miller believes that social democracy may not be the ideal to strive for in every situation therefore (ArgScheme: modus ponens) If Miller believes that social democracy may not be the ideal to strive for in every situation, then Miller is suspicious of the claim that human flourishing is always best served by democracy, Sometimes, just going along on the grounds that “they are not bothering me,” preserves the stability of a situation whose instability would represent an enormous threat therefore (ArgScheme: modus ponens) it is not clear to Miller that some willingness to surrender autonomy and authority is always an illegitimate or immoral choice, Deweyan's Social Democracy requires the free exchange of info, commitment to dialogic reciprocity and development of autonomous and authoritative judgement for each member of society therefore (ArgScheme: modus ponens) Miller believes Universal equal and unalienable rights which all persons have or ought to have is impossiible without social democracy, Miller believes Universal equal and unalienable rights which all persons have or ought to have is impossiible without social democracy therefore (ArgScheme: modus ponens) Miller believes that social democracy may not be the ideal to strive for in every situation, Universal rights, when they seem to entail the sorts of institutions we count as necessary for their fulfillment: freedoms of speech, movement assembly, and a gov't elected by the people, are not worthy of the sort of respect we assume they should command therefore (ArgScheme: modus ponens) If Universal rights, when they seem to entail the sorts of institutions we count as necessary for their fulfillment: freedoms of speech, movement assembly, and a gov't elected by the people, are not worthy of the sort of respect we assume they should command, then Miller believes that social democracy may not be the ideal to strive for in every situation, democratic social life requires fundamentally trusting other human beings to engaged in open and fair discussion of the issues invovling mutual self goverance therefore (ArgScheme: modus ponens) if democratic social life requires fundamentally trusting other human beings to engaged in open and fair discussion of the issues invovling mutual self goverance, then in a society where children are taught to obey without question, are discouraged from questioning that might reveal differences, such discussion is unlikely to occur, Without this discussion the recommendations for openness that "universal rights" entails invites situations of conflict without habits of arbitrating and engaging in such conflict productively therefore (ArgScheme: modus ponens) Miller is not aruging that universal rights should be denied based on that grounds that democratic social life may not promote their flouishing, but that it should not be encouraged in a setting where that may be the case, universal rights should not be denied on the grounds that democratic social life may not promote flourishing therefore (ArgScheme: modus ponens) Miller is suspicious of the claim that human flourishing is always best served by democracy and the conception of universal rights, democratic social life requires fundamentally trusting other human beings to engaged in open and fair discussion of the issues invovling mutual self goverance therefore (ArgScheme: modus ponens) in a society where children are taught to obey without question, are discouraged from questioning that might reveal differences, such discussion is unlikely to occur, in a society where children are taught to obey without question, are discouraged from questioning that might reveal differences, such discussion is unlikely to occur therefore (ArgScheme: modus ponens) if in a society where children are taught to obey without question, are discouraged from questioning that might reveal differences, such discussion is unlikely to occur, then Without this discussion the recommendations for openness that "universal rights" entails invites situations of conflict without habits of arbitrating and engaging in such conflict productively, democratic social life has significant preconditions in training to be autonomous and authoritative, and to value so being SUPPORTS Miller believes that social democracy may not be the ideal to strive for in every situation, Miller is not aruging that universal rights should be denied based on that grounds that democratic social life may not promote their flouishing, but that it should not be encouraged in a setting where that may be the case therefore (ArgScheme: modus ponens) if Miller is not aruging that universal rights should be denied based on that grounds that democratic social life may not promote their flouishing, but that it should not be encouraged in a setting where that may be the case, then Miller is suspicious of the claim that human flourishing is always best served by democracy, the likely possibility that open conflict of ideas and values will bring physical conflict, disruption, pain, and terror SUPPORTS Universal rights, when they seem to entail the sorts of institutions we count as necessary for their fulfillment: freedoms of speech, movement assembly, and a gov't elected by the people, are not worthy of the sort of respect we assume they should command, Universal rights, when they seem to entail the sorts of institutions we count as necessary for their fulfillment: freedoms of speech, movement assembly, and a gov't elected by the people, are not worthy of the sort of respect we assume they should command therefore (ArgScheme: modus ponens) Miller believes that social democracy may not be the ideal to strive for in every situation, Everone has the right to take part in the government of his country, directly or through freely chosen representatives SUPPORTS universal human rights entails democracy